NEGOTIATING YOUR COMPENSATION
Presented by Robert Salwen
to the Financial Executives Institute,
New York City and New Jersey Chapters,
at the Regal U.N. Plaza Hotel, New York City
May 2, 2000
1. Don’t be a deer caught in the headlights. The prospect of option riches shouldn’t blind you to the flaws in the company, the management team, the business model, or the compensation package. Do your due diligence, and approach employment offers clinically and critically.
2. Be
prepared to walk away from the deal. Companies are not accustomed to hard
bargaining of pay packages -- it’s often
countercultural for them and there’s alot of inertia and other forces
that work against you -- and they usually don’t give something up unless they
are made to. If you are not prepared to
stand your ground --- and make the company blink first -- you’re unlikely to
get what you want. Remember, not all
deals should be made. If you’re
taking alot of risk by jumping ship, the pay package should be risk adjusted to
compensate for the added risk. If it’s
not, it may not be a deal worth taking.
3. Assess
your leverage realistically. Most
executives tend to underestimate and underutilize their negotiating leverage;
they are reluctant to antagonize their future employers by negotiating
hard. Don’t assume you have more
leverage than you really do, but don’t assume you have less. If a company is making you an offer, they
want you -- and that is the time to negotiate. Once you sign on, much of your negotiating leverage dissipates. The time to negotiate is during the
courtship stage.
4. Don’t
refrain from negotiating hard out of concern about antagonizing your future
employer. It’s unlikely that you’ll
be able to extract concessions from the company without bargaining hard and
standing your ground. If you have a
realistic assessment of your leverage and you negotiate hard, you’ll be
respected coming into the organization.
It’s better to impress your future employer as a tough and sophisticated
negotiator than it is to give the impression of being a pushover.
5. Don’t
be reluctant to address the subject of divorce when you’re in the courtship
stage. This is a classic mistake that
often comes to haunt executives later.
If things don’t work out with the new company, you may not have the
leverage at that time to negotiate acceptable departure arrangements. Your leverage is at its peak during the
courtship stage, and that’s when you should hammer out the terms of any later
separation. You don’t need an
employment contract as long as everything is copacetic. You do need one when there’s a falling
out. That’s why I often say that
employment contracts really should be called unemployment contracts -- because
they are truly significant only when there is a separation.
6. Keep
your powder dry. Don’t commit prematurely. Actions speak louder than words. Getting
involved with the company, such as by attending meetings or reviewing
reports and business plans, before your employment terms are finalized, can
undermine your negotiating leverage and send a signal of weakness. Work out the
details of your compensation and employment arrangements first, and then dive
in to the work.
7. Use
intermediaries sparingly and cautiously. Most executives are quite proficient at
negotiating, and, contrary to popular belief, they don’t suddenly lose their
effectiveness when negotiating their own arrangements. The best results are often obtained when the
principals negotiate the terms directly, rather than through intermediaries
like headhunters and lawyers. Use
headhunters and lawyers as behind-the-scenes advisors, but don’t necessarily
rely on them to do the direct negotiating.
If you delegate the negotiations to your lawyer, the company will do
likewise, and at that point the lawyers, rather than the business people, tend
to dictate the terms. Executives often
obtain better results in employment negotiations when they deal directly with
their counterparts at the company, and then have the lawyers simply document
the deal that the principals have made.
8. Negotiate
by rationale. Even if you have
negotiating leverage, you usually need to provide a sound rationale to enable
the other side to accomodate your demands.
And even when one party to the negotiations lacks leverage, they can
often get what they want if they present a sound and compelling rationale.
9. Time
your negotiations carefully. Try to time your negotiations so that they take place
at auspicious times. If you’re seeking
a significant concession from the company, try to have the discussion at a time
when the other party will be in a good mood, or when your leverage is at its
apex (such as when a large deal is pending for which your services are
critical).
10. Get it
down on paper. Corporations have notoriously poor
institutional memories, as many employees who have relied on oral promises have
learned to their chagrin. Don’t rely on
oral statements or on the good faith of the person you are negotiating
with. S/he may interpret or recall
conversations very differently than you do, or s/he may no longer be with the
company (or, for that matter, alive) when the time comes for the company to
honor the promise. Get it in writing,
and get it allin writing.
Incomplete documentation can be just as troublesome as no documentation
at all.